Tuesday, September 18, 2018

The kangaroo court

Well, I see that Senators are going to call both Supreme Court nominee Kavanaugh and his accuser, Professor Christine Ford, to testify under oath on Monday before the Senate Judiciary Committee.  Considering the travesty that was the four days of Kavanaugh examination before this same committee last week, with endless public outbursts in the gallery and grandstanding by Senators on both sides of the aisle, this looks to me like nothing more than a highly partisan kangaroo court.

What, exactly, can come out of such a hearing? Ford makes the accusation, but claims she can’t remember the year it took place, the house it took place in, how she got to the party, how she got home from the party, or apparently how many people were in the room with her (she now claims two, but when she told her therapist about this some years ago, she said there were four.)  How is Kavanaugh to refute such vague claims? Predictably partisan groups have begun lining up on both sides. 63 women who knew Kavanaugh over the years, including when he was in high school, claim he has never been more than a gentlemen. Now a group of Holten Arms alumni have sided publically with Ford, who was a student there. All very emotional, but none of it is proof one way or the other. Nor is any such proof likely to emerge from the hearing. She will claim it happened. He will claim it didn’t, and none of us will know anything more than we know now.  But liberals will be absolutely sure (without proof) that she is telling the truth, and conservatives will be absolutely sure (without proof) that she is not.

But of course Democrats will have accomplished what they set out to accomplish – to stain the reputation, and perhaps prevent the seating on the Supreme Court, of a distinguished jurist with whom in fact they only have a few policy differences.  It’s disgusting, completely at variance with the principles of American law (presumed innocent until proven guilty), and worthy of some third-world despotism or police state.  Liberals think Trump is destroying democracy. From my point of view democracy has already been pretty well destroyed in Washington, and liberals are as much to blame as conservatives.

As I say, it is disgusting and everyone involved, on both sides of the aisle, ought to be ashamed of themselves. The drive for power in Washington politics has become so all-consuming that common decency has been completely lost and mob rule and trial by social media has taken its place.